Friday, November 2, 2012

Comparing Reddit, and Tumblr, and Why Having Both Will Probably Keep You Happily Away From Productivity Basically Indefinitely

This is something everyone has major opinions on on the internet, and in fact, may throw their allegiance to different sites entirely. I just happen to be affiliated mainly with those two, so I know more about them in general. However, if you expect me to be choosing one, I'm going to direct your attention back to the Old El Paso TV Commercial.

[Yeah, I'm going to get judged heavily for that one.]

That's the thing, though. Both sites hate each other's guts, though they both also consider each other minor villains compared to the horrors of 4chan and deviantart.

It goes like this: Reddit is convinced that tumblr is a bunch of teenage girls writing bad fanfiction, making crappy social justice blogs, and obsessing over doctor who. 

Tumblr is convinced that reddit is a bunch of twenty-something men making stupid jokes, complaining about how horrible their white, twenty-something lives are, and obsessing over mindcraft.

They're both kind of right. Reddit's home to a lot of jerks, and tumblr's home to a lot of crazy feminist jerks. If you weren't expecting unsavory people on the internet, you, well...

Let's just say you should expect unsavory people on the internet. It's kind of a given. 



However, I'd like to remind people before they start actually tying me to the stake: people don't notice, but both sites borrow heavily from each other. Tumblr makes it a lot easier for original content users to both display and get credit for their work and to let them distribute it quickly, whereas Reddit is simply a way to share links to a variety of other places. I hate to break it to you, redditors, but a lot of those really funny exchanges that got so many upvotes? That format's Tumblr. Sorry, Tumblr, those little facts you found so interesting? Third page of Reddit. 

I ship it.

6 comments:

  1. I tend to lean towards Tumblr. *don't mind me while I totally lean into internet gender stereotypes*

    ReplyDelete
  2. Accurate. So accurate. I used to have internal conflict over which one deserved more of my love, and was especially incensed when I heard pigheaded guys flaming Tumblr the day after seeing three Tumblr screenshots getting massive upvotes on Reddit. I've kinda leveled out -- I go on Reddit when I want a laugh, and when Tumblr is bound to crash on ancient computers, and I go on Tumblr when I want to see and publish original art/photos. I love scrolling through endless amounts of pretty on Tumblr, and I like making all the links purple on Reddit. I love you, internet.

    ReplyDelete
  3. As someone who has never used either Tumblr or Reddit (or 4chan or DeviantArt), I can still judge you for supporting both. Ha!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Reddit, Tumblr. ¿Por quĂ© no los dos?

    You make a good distinction: Reddit is slanted toward information and trivial stuff, while Tumblr is more purely artistic. Another crucial difference is that Tumblr really allows one person to broadcast stuff centered around themselves. I use Reddit almost exclusively, except for one Tumblr that reblogs rage comics. Just don't mention the words "what should we call me" in my presence.

    At least you didn't lend credence to the true villain of the internet, 9GAG. 9GAG "Repost Machine" Explained

    ReplyDelete
  5. Tumblr has a lot of pretty things (like Gloria said), although I've never really been that devoted to it. But I still like it a whole lot more than Reddit. I've never been on 4chan or deviantart, but I just don't get Reddit. Some of my male friends are reddit people and constantly show me things from there--I think the photos that they show me are funny, and I LOVE the cute animals thread/(page?), but I've never been enthusiastic about going onto reddit myself and finding funny things. The format itself is probably part of the reason--I find it so unattractive, and I'll be honest, I'm also just kind of confused about how it works. Nice post!

    ReplyDelete